Federal Judge Terrence Boyle Unfit for Promotion to Appeals Court

Judge Boyle has been reversed frequently for making the same mistakes for which he has already been reversed

In addition to being reversed repeatedly for committing plain error, Judge Boyle has also been reversed frequently for making the same or similar errors for which he had previously been reversed on appeal. This suggests, at best, an inability to learn from past mistakes and, at worst, an ideology so strong that it outweighs precedent and established law. Repetitive reversals of Judge Boyle’s rulings are particularly evident with respect to criminal sentencing, improperly granting summary judgment, and ignoring the plaintiffs’ arguments before dismissing cases.

Share this page: Facebook Twitter Digg SU Digg Delicious