People For the American Way

Governors Should Reject the Hate and Paranoia behind Trump’s National Guard Plan

People For in Action
Governors Should Reject the Hate and Paranoia behind Trump’s National Guard Plan
NOVEMBER 13 2016: Latinos, immigrants & supporters gathered 3,000 strong at Columbus Circle to protest & march against President-elect Donald Trump's proposed immigration policies

President Trump’s latest anti-immigrant salvo is to send National Guard troops to the southern border. People For the American Way won’t stand for what PFAW Political Director Lizet Ocampo called “a stunt that’s all about fanning the hate and paranoia of the far-right.” Nor should the governors whose state troops are on the line. PFAW and 44 organizational allies wrote to all 50 governors on April 12 and urged them to stand up to Trump. A copy of the letter sent to California Governor Jerry Brown follows below and is available, with signers, here.

Dear Governor Brown,

We the undersigned civil rights, advocacy, and community organizations write to ask you to join us in rejecting the xenophobia and fear that are driving calls to deploy National Guard troops to the border.

In response to news of a migrant caravan, in which women, children, and men travel together to safely reach Mexico or the United States, far-right media began raising fears and sensationalizing the story. In fact, border crossings remain at historic lows. The caravan is a reflection of individuals who want only to live in safety, and U.S. law recognizes the right of such individuals to request protection.

The border is already heavily militarized. Border Patrol is one of the largest law enforcement agencies in the country and as recently as March 23rd, when Congress denied the administration’s request to appropriate additional funds to hire more border patrol agents, the Department of Homeland Security was unable to adequately justify the need for more agents. In fact, throughout the current fiscal year, the average border patrol agent assigned to the southwest border apprehends just one person every 17 days. If we don’t need more Border Patrol agents, we definitely don’t need the National Guard.

Yet anti-immigrant and white nationalist provocateurs have latched onto this false narrative. Jeff Schwilk, a longtime anti-immigrant extremist and former Minutemen leader called the caravan a “coordinated, organized effort by foreign criminals and open border operatives to try to infiltrate our sovereign nation.” The white nationalist group Identity Evropa, whose members participated in the deadly Charlottesville protests, has started a campaign calling for the Trump administration to “stop the invasion.”

Unfortunately, far-right agitation has led President Trump to order the National Guard to the border. This decision is not based on policy considerations. Instead, it’s a response to political concerns from the president’s base. We respectfully urge you to decline to send California troops to the border.

While migrants seeking safety do not pose a security risk, far-right elements may. In 2014, women and children fleeing violence in Central America were subjected to intimidating protests from anti-immigrant activists in California and Arizona. In Murrieta, CA, buses carrying these women and children were confronted and forced to turn around and relocate to a different city. The 2018 caravan, however, has received attention from hardcore elements of the far-right that are much more prone to violence than those who protested four years ago. Public statements from governors and attorneys general denouncing vigilante violence could help dissuade these elements and avoid tragedy.

Fueling anti-immigrant and white nationalist activity with action based on this story only increases the risk of violent confrontation. We respectfully ask you to decline to send California troops to the border. We also ask that you make a public statement condemning any vigilante violence at or near the border and upholding shared values of inclusion.


anti-immigrant, border security, California, Identity Evropa, Immigration, Jeff Schwilk, Jerry Brown, letter, Minuteman Project, National Guard, xenophobia