Bush Administration Shares Right’s Hypocrisy on Religion and Judicial Nominations


Contact: Nick Berning or Josh Glasstetter at People For the American Way

Email: [email protected]

Phone Number: 202-467-4999

With statements today from influential evangelical leader James Dobson and the President himself, the hypocrisy over the role Harriet Miers’ religion is playing in her nomination continues, People For the American Way President Ralph G. Neas said today.

During previous judicial confirmation debates, including the nomination of Chief Justice John Roberts, right-wing leaders insisted that any mention of a nominee’s faith, or even indirect implication that their faith might influence their judicial opinions, would be evidence of rank religious bigotry. But the White House and the Religious Right leaders rallying around the beleaguered nomination of Harriet Miers continue to cite her religious beliefs and the church she attends as reasons to believe she will oppose abortion rights and to bolster support for her among activists on the far right.

“It’s hypocrisy doubled and quadrupled. What’s wrong for John Roberts can’t be right for Harriet Miers. Her legal views on constitutional issues must be thoroughly explored. But whether they’re shouting it from the rooftops or whispering into the ears of their right-wing supporters, Miers’ personal religious beliefs should have no place in her nomination. And those double-talking ultraconservatives who claim to be looking for a ‘strict constructionist’ to interpret the Constitution need look no further than Article VI – where the Constitution spells out that there must be no religious test for any public office,” said Neas. “The President and his people are using repeated assurances about Miers’ religion to send not-so-subtle messages about how she might rule on the court on issues important to the President’s political supporters. It’s a shabby ploy unworthy of the debate over a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court.”

Broadcaster and power broker James Dobson revealed on his show today that White House strategist Karl Rove called him before Miers’ nomination was announced publicly. Among the assurances he received from Rove, according to Dobson, were “that Harriet Miers is an Evangelical Christian” and “that she is from a very conservative church, which is almost universally pro-life.”

And today, President Bush himself defended his advisors’ use of her faith to build ultraconservative support for her candidacy. “People are interested to know why I picked Harriet Miers. They want to know Harriet Miers’ background. They want to know as much as they possibly can before they form opinions. Part of Harriet Miers’ life is her religion. Part of it has to do with the fact that she was a pioneer woman and a trailblazer in the law in Texas.”

Neas noted that the administration’s use of Miers’ faith to build support for her nomination is even troubling to some commentators on the right.

“The Constitution says there shall be no religious test for public office,” said Neas. “During previous nomination debates, right-wing leaders tried to twist that cherished constitutional principle into a ban even on asking nominees about core constitutional issues like a right to privacy. But they’ve thrown it out the window to convince right-wing activists that Harriet Miers will be the kind of justice they want.”